Pot pies… those wonderful savory pies are such a classic comfort food. Meat and veggies in a creamy gravy all enveloped in a flaky crust… so, so good.
While everyone may know the basic chicken pot pie, they can be made in so many varieties. That’s why we decided to compile this list of the best Pot Pie Recipes for you.
From classics like chicken and beef, to exotic flavors and even food fusions like taco pot pie and bacon cheeseburger pot pie, you’ll find plenty of great savory pies here.
Cook your way through this delicious list, maybe you’ll find a new family favorite!
1. Crustless Rotisserie Chicken Pot Pie Casserole
We are starting the list with Pot pie without the pie.. Yes, if you are like me craving those comfy, cozy flavors without the extra work. This one is for those lazy days.
2. Chicken Pot Pie
Chicken pot pie.. Classic recipes are popular for a reason, they’re absolutely delicious! This chicken pot pie is made from complete scratch, and it’s filled with creamy chicken and vegetables.
3. Pastel De Choclo
Pastel de choclo… It’s a great comfort food that mixes classic shepherd’s pie with South American culture. It can be intimidating to try out different food, but trust us when we say that this one is definitely worth a try!
4. Leftover Turkey Pot Pie
Sometimes you just want to make a recipe without needing to gather a bunch of new ingredients, and not have to cook things you aren’t familiar with. This leftover turkey pot pie uses leftovers and ingredients you’ll already have, so you don’t need to shop.
5. Beef Pot Pie
Everybody loves comfort food, and this beef pot pie is the perfect definition of comfort food. The beef is super tender and deeply flavored, and the meat is sure to melt right in your mouth. It’s also filled with vegetables that complement the beef flavors wonderfully, to complete the pot pie.
6. Cottage Ground Beef Pot Pie
This cottage ground beef pot pie uses potatoes and parsnips, and it’s a super easy meal to make, because it only uses one pan. It’s got hearty, rich flavors, and it’s filled with lean ground beef, peas, carrots, parsnips, and potatoes.
7. Seafood Pot Pie
Seafood pot pie sounds crazy at first, but if you try making this seafood pot pie yourself, you’ll be sure to fall in love with it. It’s made with frozen shrimp, imitation crab, and a perfectly crusted pie crust. Try it out yourself!
8. Breakfast Biscuit Pot Pie
Who says you can’t have a pot pie for breakfast? We certainly don’t, and neither does this breakfast biscuit pot pie. Not only is it deliciously buttery, but it’s also filled to the brim with great ingredients like sausage, eggs, and peppers.
9. Taco Pot Pie
As you may have seen in some of our previous collections, turning recipes into tacos is a popular and delicious trend, and it continues here with this taco pot pie! It’s filled with traditional taco ingredients, and it’s served warm and covered in sour cream.
10. Ham Pot Pie
One of the great things about food is that it can be simple without being boring – which is exactly how to describe this ham pot pie. It’s a terrific traditional pot pie recipe, that’s super easy to make and filled with both vegetables and ham.
11. Slow Cooker Chicken Pot Pie
Another chicken recipe on our list is this slow cooker chicken pot pie recipe. It’s one of the easiest pot pies to make, and it’s made from scratch, so you won’t be using any store bought cream of chicken soup for this dish!
12. Aussie Meat Pie
Looking to make a pot pie Australian style? Check out this Aussie meat pie! It uses carmazeled meat and vegetables that are coated in gravy, baked under a crispy golden brown crust. It’s perfect to make for the whole family.
13. Spicy Lamb and Beet Pot Pie
You’re definitely going to fall in love with this spicy lamb and beet pot pie! It’s a perfect dish to make if you need something to warm you up, because both the heat and the spice will help with that! Even if it’s not cold out, it’s too great to pass up.
14. Mediterranean Chicken Pot Pie
Mediterranean-style chicken is popular for a reason, and if you haven’t tried it, now is your chance! This Mediterranean chicken pot pie is also a great way to make use of any and all leftovers you may have sitting around the house.
15. Butter Chicken Pot Pie
Everyone’s favorite butter chicken in Pot Pie Form.. How delicious!! The recipe uses a delicious naan crust that helps make the pot pie more creative and flavorful.
16. BBQ Chicken Cornbread Pot Pie
The BBQ chicken in this pot pie is hearty and tasty! It doesn’t stop at the beautiful BBQ chicken, because this pot pie is topped with a perfectly cheesy cornbread to add even more flavors to the pot pie.
17. Mushroom Pot Pie
Chances are, you’ve never had a pot pie with mushrooms before. Whether you have or you haven’t, this mushroom pot pie is sure to impress and become a household staple. If you want a pot pie for dinner but want to mix things up, this mushroom pot pie is for you.
18. Beef Stroganoff Pot Pies
They’re comforting, they’re warming, they’re beef stroganoff pot pies! They’re super easy to make, and they can be made in a slow cooker. The beef is mixed inside the pie with a creamy sauce that brings the whole thing together.
19. Creamy Fish Pot Pies
Another easy to make and delicious pot pie recipe is this creamy fish pot pie. They’re perfect for if you want to make a dinner in advance, because you can easily freeze them and make them ready for tomorrow, or next week’s, dinner.
20. Andouille Sausage and Chicken Pot Pie
This andouille sausage and chicken pot pie uses ingredients that are easily accessible, and pretty common – so you might already have them laying around the house. Combining that with an easy to make recipe and you’ve got a perfect match!
21. Biscuits and Gravy Pie
Biscuits and gravy are a classic pairing, and what better way to celebrate the pairing than with a biscuits and gravy pot pie? It uses sausage gravy that’s thick and creamy, topped with golden brown biscuits, and they’re all mixed into the buttery pie crust.
22. Chili Pot Pie
Another great recipe for the colder seasons is this chili pot pie. It’s served in a spectacular homemade cornbread crust, and it’s so warm and tasty it’s great not just when it’s cold, but all year round! If you don’t believe us, try it out yourself!
23. Cheddar Broccoli Chicken Pot Pie
We’ve gone over a lot of classic pairings in our recipe collections, and we’ve got another one here – cheddar and broccoli. This cheddar broccoli chicken pot pie is simply fabulous.
24. Brazilian Chicken Pot Pie
This Brazilian chicken pot pie, also known as Empadão de Frango, is amazing! It claims to be the best chicken pie in the world, and it just might be! The pot pie is made up of buttery and flaky crust, and it’s filled with creamy filling.
25. Bacon Cheeseburger Pot Pie
Bacon cheeseburgers have a lot of fans, and this recipe will bring together lovers of bacon cheeseburgers and pot pies! It’s super quick and easy to make, which makes it a perfect meal for a school nights or a hungry family.
26. Instant Pot Mini Chicken Curry Pot Pies
Nothing beats being able to use an instant pot to make your dinner, and these instant pot mini chicken curry pot pies are absolutely adorable. The crust holds a coconut curry filling, and the flavors combine to make a phenomenal pot pie.
27. Creamy Vegetable Pot Pie
Many people prefer having their vegetables creamy, like in the form of creamed spinach. While they aren’t quite as creamy as that, this recipe uses wonderful veggies in a creamy vegetable pot pie, which is a perfect mix between solid veggies and having them totally creamed.
28. Samosa Pot Pie
Looking for something that’s lightly spiced, crispy, and delicious? Try out this samosa pot pie. It’s a wonderful combination of, you guessed it, a samosa and a pot pie. It is absolutely wonderful, and it’s also vegetarian, making it a great meal for everyone.
29. Pizza Pot Pie
Who doesn’t love pizza? You can satisfy the pizza fans and the pot pie fans all at once with this pizza pot pie! They’re personal sized, which makes them already perfectly sized for a one person meal, so they’re a hit at a party or a dinner for one!
30. Steak and Mushroom Ale Pie
This steak and mushroom ale pie is creative, tasty, and melts in your mouth. It’s inspired by the best British pubs, and it’s sure to impress, regardless of whether you’re in the UK, the US, or somewhere else in the world.
There you have it, thirty amazing pot pie recipes for you to try. They all look so good, which one to bake first?
Bookmark or pin this collection so you always know where to go when the homemade pot pie craving hits. And be sure to subscribe to the GypsyPlate mailing list, we’re always cooking up new recipes for you!
- 2 1/2 cups all-purpose flour
- 1/2 Tbsp sugar
- 1/2 tsp salt
- 2 sticks cold unsalted butter, cut into 1/4" pieces
- 7 Tbsp ice water
- Put flour, sugar and salt into a food processor and pulse until mixed.
- Add butter and pulse until the mixture forms coarse crumbs.
- Add ice water and pulse until moist clumps form. Feel the dough. If it is not slightly sticky, add a little more water.
- Transfer dough to a floured surface. Divide in half and roll into two flat disks. Cover with plastic wrap and refrigerate 1 hour before using.
- Let me know which recipes you try, I love hearing from you!
Never miss a recipe!
Join the GypsyPlate mailing list and get easy dinner recipes right in your mailbox. From homestyle comfort food to exotic dishes from around the world.